The Painted Pedigree

---

As curators of The Painted Pedigree, one of our goals is to reintroduce visitors to the true visual history of the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel—long before the breed bore that name.

Historically, the dogs we now recognize as Cavaliers were known simply as Toy Spaniels, Comforters, or Lap Dogs. They appear in paintings, tapestries, and literature as early as the 16th century, often by the sides of royalty, aristocrats, or children. These dogs were not categorized by today's standards, but their physical features—long muzzles, elegant frames, diverse coloring—are unmistakably tied to what we now call the Cavalier.

In the late 1800s and early 1900s, selective breeding led Toy Spaniels toward a shorter muzzle, domed head, and flatter face. These dogs became known as King Charles Spaniels, the forerunners of today’s English Toy Spaniel. But in the 1920s, a movement began to revive the older type—the long-faced, sporting Toy Spaniel seen in historic art. This effort eventually led to the formal recognition of the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel as a distinct breed.

So, while you won’t see the word “Cavalier” in 17th- or 18th-century art catalogs, you will see the ancestors of the Cavalier—living proof of their presence long before the breed was officially defined. That’s why we’ve chosen to organize this museum around imagery, not modern registry labels. Because the art tells the truth.

In The Painted Pedigree, every brushstroke is a breadcrumb. These historical artworks don’t just depict beloved pets—they capture true-to-life representations of dogs that lived long before photography existed. In eras when painters served the role of both artist and documentarian, accuracy wasn’t just expected—it was essential. Their reputation, commissions, and artistic legacy depended on capturing detail with precision.

That’s why the colors and features we see in these portraits matter so much. They are often our only visual proof of what existed, especially for coat colors and physical traits not acknowledged in modern breed standards.

Here are key markers we look for:

• Lighter Eyes & Liver-Colored Noses:
  When you see Cavaliers in artwork with hazel or amber eyes and pinkish-brown (liver) noses, you're likely looking at a chocolate Cavalier. These traits correlate with the bb gene (chocolate/liver) and are genetically consistent with modern chocolate-colored dogs today.
   
• Black & White Spaniels Without Tan Points:
  Your instinct may say “tricolor,” but stop and look again. If the tan points are absent, these are not modern tris—they are black and whites, a color combination historically present but now virtually erased from breed narratives.
   
• Solid Blacks Mistaken for Black & Tan:
  In some portraits, dogs appear jet black but lack the expected tan above the eyes, on the chest, or legs. These are not black and tans. They are solid black Cavaliers, a color that once existed naturally but is no longer recognized in current standards.
   

These distinctions matter because they reinforce a larger truth:
The Cavaliers we see today are not the only Cavaliers that ever existed. These paintings give voice to the forgotten colors—the ones that registry books ignored, but artists preserved. The Painted Pedigree honors that legacy by letting the past speak through paint, canvas, and careful observation.

While they weren’t called Cavaliers yet, their features—long ears, large eyes, compact size, feathered coats—match breed standards perfectly. These dogs were painted centuries before kennel clubs existed. They didn’t change—we just renamed them. 

Because breed standards didn’t exist to filter them out. Before registration rules, Cavaliers appeared in solid black, black & white, chocolate, liver & white, and more. Over time, certain colors were written out—not because they disappeared, but because they were no longer accepted as in fashion. 

They were slowly bred out or labeled as “mismarks.” But genetic data and historic art confirm they were once common. These colors weren’t rare—they were erased. 

As photography replaced portraiture and breed clubs tightened control, visual diversity faded. The more control we gained through standards, the more visual truth we lost. That’s why this museum bridges the gap. 

Yes. Though rare, chocolates, solids, and black & whites still exist in small numbers thanks to preservation breeders. The Painted Pedigree isn’t just history—it’s proof of survival. 

Yes. Color doesn’t determine purity—genetics and history do. All Cavaliers descend from the same roots. What’s been hidden isn’t the dog—it’s the recognition. 

Everything.

Whether your Cavalier is ruby, Blenheim, black and tan, tricolor—or one of the rare historical colors we’ve unearthed here—one truth remains:

They did not begin with their parents.

Your Cavalier is the result of centuries of lineage, love, and evolution. Just like you weren’t created by one generation, neither were they. Behind every soft gaze and wagging tail is a family tree that reaches back hundreds of years—to manor halls, royal courts, artist studios, and firesides. What you see in these paintings isn’t just “some other dog.” It’s a window into your Cavalier’s great-grandparents to the 64th power.

And yet, much of that history is being erased.

When clubs decide which colors are acceptable, which coats are fashionable, and which dogs “belong,” they’re not just rewriting standards—they’re amputating ancestry. They’re turning legacy into trend.

We hope, before you scroll away, that you take one last look at your Cavalier—curled up beside you or pictured in your heart—and realize they carry more history than you were ever told. That black-and-white portrait? That chocolate pup with the lighter eyes? They’re not accidents. They’re echoes.

This museum isn’t here to challenge your love—it’s here to defend it.

Because loving the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel means loving its whole story—even the parts others tried to paint over.